When maintaining a grill, an efficient charcoal tray is essential for even heat, easier ash management, and longer grill life. This guide highlights five highly compatible charcoal trays that fit a range of popular grills, from Char-Griller models to Weber and Smoke Hollow. Each option emphasizes durability, high-temperature resistance, and practical design features like removable or adjustable racks. Use the buying guide to compare sizes, materials, and compatibility with your existing setup.
| Product | Brand | Key Size (L x W) | Notable Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Inch Ash Pan Replacement | Burly grill | 20″ x 12.75″ | With 2 grate hangers for easy disassembly |
| Napoleon Grills Charcoal & Smoker Tray | Napoleon | — | Includes smoker option; fits most Napoleon gas grills |
| 27 Inch Ash Pan Replacement | MOASKER | 27″ x 13″ | Includes 2 fire grate hangers |
| 15-28 Inch Stretchable Tray | JCLMER | 15.15″ – 28″ (length) x 13″ (width) | Retractable for versatile sizing |
| 27 Inch Ash Pan Replacement | LS’BABQ | 27″ x 13″ | Wide compatibility with various grill models |
20 Inch Ash Pan Replacement for Char Griller
The Burly grill 20 inch charcoal ash pan is designed as a replacement part for Chargriller models including 5050, 5072, 2123, 2223, 2823, and 5650. It also serves as a suitable charcoal tray for Char Griller 200157. The tray measures 20 inches in length and 12 3/4 inches in width, providing ample capacity for charcoal and ash management during longer cooks. It features two grate hangers to simplify disassembly and movement. Constructed from high-quality solid steel with a powder-coated finish, the tray is described as anti-rust and heat resistant, aiming for longer service life. This option emphasizes ease of cleaning—ash can be dumped and the tray rinsed to keep the grill looking like new.
Features a sturdy build intended to withstand repeated heating cycles. While the specific model fit is targeted toward Chargriller variants, the tray’s dimensions and hanger design make it a practical upgrade for many mid-size charcoal grills with similar layouts.
Napoleon Grills Commercial Charcoal Tray
The Napoleon 67732 commercial charcoal and smoker tray is designed to fit a broad range of Napoleon gas grills. It features a cast iron construction for durability and heat retention, and it includes a smoker option for added versatility. While the listing notes compatibility with many Napoleon models, the emphasis remains on solid construction that supports both charcoal grilling and smoking. This tray can enhance heat management by providing a dedicated area for charcoal while allowing the grill to perform as a smoker when needed.
Ideal for users seeking a robust, long-lasting tray that can handle high temperatures and provide smoker capability. Potential drawbacks include model-specific fit considerations, so confirming model compatibility before purchase is recommended.
MOASKER 27 Inch Ash Pan Replacement
The MOASKER 27 inch ash pan replacement targets Char Griller models such as 1224, 1324, 2121, 2222, 2727, 2828, 2929, and E1224, as well as Charbroil variants 17302056 and CB056-036. This tray includes two fire grate hangers and measures 27 inches by 13 inches. The set is marketed as a replacement for Kingsford charcoal barrel grills and is built from a durable material described as capable of withstanding high temperatures. This option is suitable for users replacing worn ash pans on larger, multi-grate grills and those who require a long, wide tray with additional hanger support for easier maintenance.
Consider compatibility with your specific model’s grate arrangement and ensure the included hangers align with your grill’s design. The 27-inch length offers substantial charcoal capacity for longer cooks.
JCLMER 15-28 Inch Stretchable Tray
The JCLMER stretchable charcoal tray is designed for multiple grill models, including Pit Boss Memphis I, Expert 24, Chargriller 2190, PS9900, 47183T, PS9500, 6500, 6800, 8500, SH5000, SH7000, SH9916, HC4518L, SH19030119, SH19030219, and Nexgrill 810-0029. The tray is adjustable from 15.15 inches to 28 inches in length and has a consistent width of 13 inches, enabling compatibility with various grill footprints. It features a high-temperature powder-coated stainless steel construction intended to resist bending and warping and to withstand prolonged exposure to heat. The retractable design aids in storage and mode-changing between cooking setups.
Pros include broad compatibility and a sleek retractable mechanism for flexible usage. Consumers should verify model-specific fit and ensure the tray’s width and mounting points align with their grill’s design to avoid interference with vents or grates.
LS’BABQ 27 Inch Charcoal Ash Pan
LS’BABQ offers a 27-inch ash pan replacement compatible with Chargriller models 1224, 1324, 2121, 2222, 2727, 2828, 2929, and Charbroil options such as 17302056 and CB056-036. This tray includes two fire grate hangers and features a wide compatibility claim that extends to various charcoal barrel grills and Kingsford-style setups. The tray is constructed from aluminum steel for strength and heat resistance and is designed to hold a substantial amount of charcoal while reducing ash spill. Durability and rust resistance are highlighted characteristics for repeated use in high-heat grilling sessions.
As with other stretch or fixed trays, verify exact model fit and mounting points. The 27-inch length provides ample capacity for longer cooks, and the included hangers facilitate easier cleaning and maintenance.
Buying Guide: Key Purchase Considerations
- Model compatibility: Always verify that the tray fits your grill’s make and model. Some trays are designed for specific brands (Char-Griller, Weber, Smoke Hollow, Napoleon), while others claim broad compatibility. Check part numbers, mounting points, and grate configurations.
- Size and capacity: Consider the tray’s length, width, and overall capacity. Stretchable or adjustable trays offer flexibility, but fixed trays may provide superior rigidity for high-heat use. Ensure the tray accommodates your typical charcoal load and ash capacity without obstructing vents or grates.
- Material and coating: High-temperature steel or aluminum-steel composites with powder coating resist rust and warping. Anti-rust coatings extend service life but confirm that coatings won’t chip when cleaning with brushes or detergents.
- Hangers and mounting hardware: Some trays include grate hangers or mounting hardware for quick assembly and disassembly. Having hangers can simplify ash removal and grate maintenance, but verify compatibility with your grill’s internal layout.
- Cleaning and maintenance: Easy-to-clean trays reduce cooking downtime. Powder coatings and non-stick surfaces can facilitate ash removal and rinse cleaning between cooks without damaging the tray.
- Durability under heat and load: Look for thick walls and reinforced seams to resist bending under heavy charcoal loads. Stainless or high-strength steel alloys perform better for long-term use in charbroiled cooking environments.
- Price-to-value: Compare initial cost to expected lifespan and replacement intervals. A slightly higher upfront price may yield longer service life and lower maintenance costs over time.
- Maintenance routine: Regular cleaning, thorough drying, and proper ash disposal help prolong tray life. Consider a tray with removable components for easier cleaning where applicable.